Tuesday, 19 February 2019

Furor over faith

Image credit: Hindustan Times
On the day of Valentine’s, when couples express their love and affection for each other, a horrifying event unfolded in Kashmir. The terror attack on a CRPF convoy claimed 40 lives in Pulwama in late afternoon, one that was described as a deafening explosion by witnesses on the scene. Over the last 4 days, you have come across the saddening reports of the ghastly attack in news media sprinkled with a dose of rage and retribution. We all noticed the live coverage and prime time segments on news channel over the incident for 3 consecutive days. And there then, it started, a campaign for chest-thumping hyper nationalism with overdose of patriotic hashtags on social media.

The outrage over the dastardly attack carried by a terrorist was driven by emotional sentiments which was justified to the extent where we felt as One Country, One People united at a time of grief and mourning for our martyrs. Indians, rich and poor, kids and adults, men and women, all came under one banner to condemn the atrocity, and console the families of those fallen heroes. Candle light marches and vigils in the name of those martyrs flooded the streets along with a string of international solidarity behind our back. The narrative turned upside down when some “over sentimentalists” mistaken public outrage as calls for public action.

Image credit: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis
Image credit: REUTERS/Mukesh Gupta
We all ran across the visuals of rail roko in Mumbai suburban railways to car torching in Delhi to outright destruction of public property in Jammu. The chaos and havoc invoked due to the overdose of sentiments and miscreant behaviour of some clearly disrupted the day for thousands of others. Targeting Kashmiri students and tenants in cities like Dehradun was another sickening episode in the saga of wilderness staged by the fanatic few. The fuel for that fire was overtly dispensed by the fundamentalists on TV news panels and far-right preachers of blind patriotism. What should have been peaceful foot marches with the Tricolor became violent rowdiness on triple seated bikes fluttering Saffron flags. The underlying idea and intent behind such display was undimmed with the hands and face of the puppeteers luminously visible.

The fact that the person who carried out the attack was a ‘Kashmiri’ youth, not ‘Indian’, resonates a well orchestrated campaign in the media to distinguish Kashmiris with the rest of India. A native to the state of Jammu and Kashmir, an integral part of India, Adil Ahmad Dar, 22, was a local of the place where he carried out his attack. Influenced and radicalized by Jaish-e-Mohammad and alienated by the activities of the state, he resorted to the gravest of grave act for a cause he believed was driven by religious appropriation and freedom struggle. The question, the people in power and media but also the common man, failed to ask is why this happened in the first place? Why that feeling of alienation budded inside his heart? Why that promising young mind diverted attention from intellectual development to extremist propaganda? Why JeM found a diehard recruit across the border on Indian soil? Why he enjoyed sympathies in the hearts of those few in our side of the border? These are some straight solid questions that we failed to get answers from our establishment. Will you agree if I say that we all are partly responsible for the mess festering in that region for decades? Isn’t there a need for introspection among the establishment, the media and the people to get answers? We hail ourselves as the largest democracy in the world while constantly overlooking the rampant tossing of civil and electoral liberties of people whom we still hesitate to call “Indian”. And mind when I say, its not just about Kashmir but also the states at the Eastern edge of the Himalayas.

Then comes to the question of retaliation and retribution. While I prefer not to comment on the heavy words used by our political leadership and the actual weight it carries, I notice that the chest thumping, saffron clad patriots on the streets and on T.V. are distantly floating aboard a dicey boat with perilous ideas. With arguments ranging from nuclear annihilation of Pakistan to indiscriminate shootings of Pakistanis currently in India to launching airstrikes over Karachi, I am sure you too are baffled by the very words of it. Such war-mongering attitudes erupt every time there are cross border militant activities with high casualties, both civilian and military. Remember the tough talks of 2001-02 after the Parliament attack, 2006 bombings of Mumbai suburban trains and the gruesome massacre of men, women and children during the three day siege of 26/11, all brought the mass opinion in favour of such actions. What saved us then and what will save us now is we detest ourselves from such desolate thoughts that are championed by ill-advised and naive minds.

The much lauded and politicized Surgical Strikes post-Uri is a lucid example of the magnitude and limits to our tactical and strategic response. The Bollywood blockbuster of last month, Uri, garnered applause for its depiction of the strikes but very few underlined the ripple effect it’ll implode overtime, whose shock waves are already being felt. Uri, with due respect to its heroic storyline, is a catalyst that’s invoking a new brand of “blockbuster machismo” that feeds to the commoner’s imagination that military action is the answer for all problems and a nationalist political leadership can green light that effort. However the argument slip to gauge the merits of its accomplishments and more so, the collateral damage accompanied. There is a reason that such classified activities in Western countries are concealed from the public for a period of time and only years later can a filmmaker gain access to the story for adaptation. In the temptation to gain political mileage and storm the box office, politicians and filmmakers alike have started capitalizing on sensitive military accomplishments for votes and notes. Audience too are getting carried away in this ride not recognizing the genuine narrative independence and autonomy that the armed forces require.
 
 Image credit: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis
As to the response you think India should give, will be best to keep under the realm of the military and the top political leadership. They are far more tuned and well versed with the economics of retaliation. If we wish to make a change and obscurely punish the perpetrators, let’s start with the small things we can do to harm them. It is a well known fact that our giant neighbor China has repeatedly blocked India’s attempt to designate JeM chief Masood Azhar as a global terrorist in the UN and its subordinate agencies. Worse so, the Chinese response to the Pulwama attacks, both through its foreign office and state media, has been tepid and seen to bend heavily in Pakistan’s favour. Their all-weather alliance banked on Chinese debt-funded Pakistani hopes to keep afloat its ailing economy and strategic access to Arabian Sea in return is a tight knot of dependence. By this, we can understand why its critical for the Chinese to prop up its increasingly isolated ally. To inflict pain on China, we as common citizens can cut purchases of cheap Chinese goods that they have flooded in our market and so help our domestic industry. Dumping the Dragon’s coercive policies can to a mild extent, be a befitting response. Instead of destroying public and private property of fellow Indians, chest-thumpers can boycott cheap Chinese goods, hurting their extravagant trade surplus ($50 billion+) over India, and there they can have a sweet taste of revenge.

At the end, its all a matter of time that we’ll start to see what the establishment does or does not. Having faith in their capacity and trust in their judgement is the best we can do for our martyred heroes. Contributing to charity funds that’ll help their families and praying for their well-being is a service that’s virtuous. So lets heal ourselves of our grief and stay united while keeping away chest-thumping hyper nationalists from setting the stage.

2 comments:

  1. While it is true that a well thought out response executed over a period of time would be appropriate, The chest thumping serves a purpose too...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading and sharing your thought 😄

      Delete