Wednesday, 19 June 2019

Agony and Apathy


From past few days, I have been morbid with lamenting news of the deaths of children in Bihar caused due to a sporadic outbreak of Acute Encephalitis Syndrome (AES) epidemic. Unheard of, I came across reports online that tried to explain this fatal disease. Attributed to various factors such as malnutrition, heat, humidity and unhygienic conditions, the disease has in a matter of weeks claimed 108 lives in Bihar as per official government figures. However conflicting reports in media suggest the numbers to be much higher, as high as 150.

Over 350 cases have been reported across hospitals in Bihar with the town of Muzaffarpur being the hardest hit. A round the clock coverage of this public health emergency in media has kept many in the country on their hooks. That prompted the state government and the administration to come out of their long slumber and respond to an ever intensifying public health crisis.

Children showing symptoms of AES undergoing treatment at Sri Krishna Medical College and Hospital (SKMCH), in Muzaffarpur. (Image: PTI)
Yeah, it took the state government a national media coverage and rising public anger over the issue to wake up and take note. Chief Minister Nitish Kumar only visited the overburdened Sri Krishna Medical College Hospital in Muzaffarpur on Tuesday, much to witness the uproar over his government’s negligence in the matter. Barely spending an hour meeting not with grief-struck families of the dead children, but with the doctors and hospital management, Kumar left the crowd in complete displeasure over his clumsy, face-saving visit. Even the media was made to stay yards away from him to dodge their hard hitting questions.

This appalling display of ineptitude, arrogance and antipathy is just a poster picture for the deep rooted problem the Indian Public Healthcare System has grown accustomed to. Over the weekend a different crisis overwhelmed the country, a doctors’ strike over poor working conditions and lack of state security from physical abuse. The two junior doctors assaulted by relatives of a deceased man in Kolkata on June 10 still remain under medical care. In late May, a gynaecology student in Mumbai - Payal Tadvi - committed suicide over caste discrimination and harassment which she alleged was institutional in her college.

Medical students and doctors hold placards during a strike in protest to condemn the attack on some of their colleagues in West Bengal. File Photo - PTI
Tadvi, aged 26, committed suicide on May 22 by hanging herself in her hostel room in BYL Nair hospital. P.C. - The Indian Express
These are just a few of the many distressing contemporary events that have been rocking the healthcare system for years. India is way behind in public healthcare standards than even its immediate developing economy peers like China and Indonesia.

So let’s make you familiar with some facts. According to the National Health Profile, 2018 published by the Union government, India spends a dismal 1.3% of its GDP on healthcare, way below the global average of 6%. That means an average of just Rs 3 is spent per day by the government on an Indian. The fiscal allocation in the interim budget tabled on February 1 this year is sixty one thousand crores. There is just one doctor for every 11,082 individuals, which is 10 times more than the World Health Organization (WHO) recommended doctor-population ratio of 1:1,000. Bihar has a ratio of 1:28,391 which speaks volume of the overburdened state healthcare system.

Source: NHP report 2018
By this it can be understood that our country lacks the necessary public expenditure needed to build good healthcare facilities. Yes, the population is huge, but if China can have a 1.8:1,000 ratio, then why can’t we better our levels. The National Health Policy, 2017 targets 2.5% of GDP to be spent on public healthcare by 2025, something which now seems overzealous. States in the North, Central and Eastern parts of India have a significantly lower share of budget expenditure on healthcare compared to well-faring Southern states.

The Modi government last year introduced the Ayushman Bharat health insurance scheme to cover 50 crore poor, uninsured people in the safety net. “Modicare” has been dubbed as an important program, but fails to impact on some of the most fundamental challenges to public healthcare, quality and quantity. A health insurance is useless if there isn’t a good hospital in close proximity with adequate number of beds and a well trained cadre of health professionals along with necessary infrastructure, devices and equipment and above all - affordable medicines. This list of requirements cannot be ignored in any health policy, even at the municipal level.

Contrary to the popular belief that Indian parents are settled on two main career options for their children - engineer or doctor - and hence their share in workforce is high, the previous ratio figure is an eye-opener. We just don’t have enough health professionals in our labour force with respect to demand and hence need to increase their share. India till date relies on medical education that isn’t keeping track of lightening progress in life sciences and not in sync with new age medical technologies. Our health professionals need to be trained in the best standards of education and practices adopted across the world. Integration of Artificial Intelligence, impetus on Research and Development and producing top-class medical journals should now be the focus of Health Education.

Over the past few decades, the private healthcare industry has grown rapidly in the urban clusters of India. The hospital industry is forecasted to increase to Rs 8.6 Lakh Crore by FY22 from Rs 4 Lakh Crore in FY17 at a CAGR of 16-17 per cent. A rising middle class is now ready to spend on private healthcare, driving the prices high and keeping it out of reach for the poorer populace. The state needs to step in to fill the widening price gap. Hence, a lot of investment is required in rural India to tend to the healthcare needs of 2/3rds of Indians living there.

Health infrastructure would need private as well as public investments to make hospitals and clinics more accessible to remote communities. A wide network of Primary Healthcare Centers (PHCs) in Panchayat level areas with dedicated wards for women and children is necessary to avoid a Muzaffarpur-like crisis happening again. The early stages of recognizing symptoms, conducting tests and initial treatment would come under these primary centers.

The secondary and tertiary care institutions should also be within reach of rural communities. Here, the private sector needs to command the baton. Bringing new age technology with the advent of internet penetration, telemedicine and cost effective AI solutions can play a key role to raise healthcare standards. A hospital staff that connects and communicates to illiterate patients the most technical explanation in understandable terms can wedge the knowledge gap. Building such expertise should be given priority.

Cost of healthcare is another big hurdle to cross. It is a widely accepted notion that families in India refrain from accessing healthcare facilities to avoid costs even if it means living with pain and troubles. Households are tight budgeted and spending on a doctor or a check-up is seen as a luxury, not a necessity. This mentality needs to change and can only happen if the cost of healthcare is brought down. In that aspect, the government has done some praiseworthy job by drastically cutting the prices of essential drugs and medical equipment. The cost of undergoing a dialysis has come down, so has the treatment for cancer due to drug price cuts. Now more needs to be done to bring down costs in other critical segments.

Lastly, heathcare needs to be a prominent topic of discussion in politics and policy. I note that elections in India are fought on everything, from Mandir to Mandal and Parivaar to Pakistan. The three major issues (3Ps as I would call) that are always eclipsed by the toxic clouds of the former are public healthcare, public education and pollution. We really need our representatives to dedicate more time, energy and resources to address these topics.

The grief over the loss of their children cannot be compensated by any government grant (4 lakh as announced) to those families. How can money be weighed on the same scale with a child? How can those doctors thrashed by kins of their patient get back into practicing the most noble profession in the world with spirit? How can an aspiring doctor ever be one if her own academic circle berates her on her identity and roots? The agony of everyone is for us to see, worse comes with a visible apathy from those we expect to solve the problems. Its time that we recognise them all as part of us and demand action to better ourselves.

After all, health is wealth!

Tuesday, 14 May 2019

On the edge of Fascist revival

Days ago, the world observed the 74th anniversary of the end of Second World War in Europe. The liberation of Nazi-occupied Europe by Western Allied forces and the Soviet Red Army concluded with the capture of Berlin and the suicidal death of the War’s homicidal perpetrator - Adolf Hitler. His patron, the founder of Fascism - Benito Mussolini - met a similar death by gunshot, except that it was by the hands of those he brutally oppressed. The fatal demise of the two dictators led to the subsequent fall of Fascism and the rise of two distinct socio-political ideology - Liberal Democracy and Communism.

The world has come a long way from the horrors of the previous Century and the constant ideological clashes of the time. Communism fell after men with sledgehammers tore down the Berlin Wall in ‘89. That spectacular moment made the victory of Liberal Democracy eminent. The East and West came under the umbrella of the New Age of Globalism and Multilateralism. Borders opened, people migrated, cultures exchanged, economies boomed, technology advanced; all of this happening at a remarkable pace never witnessed before.

Leaders in politics and business hailed the benefits of a free, open and global society. Media reverberated the ethos of multiculturalism and social cohesiveness. Such rank-and-file politicians along with their business patrons and media moguls dominated the intellectual space of democratic countries. Mature democracies of the West and new emerging giants in the developing world fastened their seat belts for a joyride; one that would soon prove bumpy.

The rapid prosperity brought on by liberalism soon turned foul for communities that felt left out of or let down by it. The cheer of an open society turned cacophonies in the ears of the West as it witnessed the terror unleashed during 9/11 and the subsequent bombings in London and Madrid through the 2000s. The perpetrators espousing an extremist rendition of Islam turned the tide of sentiment and prejudice against the Muslim world. The U.S.-led War on Terror destabilized the Middle East and provoked extremist backlash.

Then came the economic downfall of 2008-09 as the Global Financial Crisis wiped out much of the world’s wealth drawn in during boom years. Unemployment surged, public debt skyrocketed and households were left with nothing as savings. Governments that trumpeted the values of free market globalism came under fire for allowing crony capitalism and corporate greed go unchecked. Protests like “Occupy Wall Street” drew prolific crowds with chants calling for the downfall of globalism.

Austerity measures in bankrupt economies of Europe, Asia and Latin America killed the little affinity people had in their elected leaders. Long entrenched corruption and soaring income inequality added fuel to the fire. Simmering anger against the out-of-touch political class reached a boiling point. There then, the public resentment became the perfect breeding ground for populism and its champions. Flag bearers of national revival and socio-economic conservatism paraded the streets of rural and semi-urban hinterland.

“The establishment is CROOKED”, became the war cry for populists - canvassing people to overthrow the alleged feudalism of “liberal elites”. Politicians, corporations and media were lampooned for everything that was wrong with the country. Intellectuals were questioned on their rationalism as they failed to defend its ethos over public dissatisfaction. But this populism took an ugly turn when signs of fascist tendencies emerged.

Anthropologists observe that when societies see economic and political hardships, they often find an element to blame. In this case, the perfect point of blame went to two sections; the political establishment and migrants. The European Refugee Crisis of 2015 and the Open Door policies adopted by many Western countries thundered the populists there to decry immigration. Islamophobia as a result of frequent terror attacks and xenophobia because of fear of natives’ economic depredation  catapulted public opinion in favor of populists.

The nexus between them and (rather orthodox) religious conservatives - who felt ostracized under liberal establishment - carried homophobic and anti-feminist attitude. Under-veiled misogyny became overt, while communalism and antisemitic rhetoric turned mainstream. The lines of separation of Church and State - basic principle of a secular democracy - became blurred. This ideology came to be reckoned as modern day ‘neo-fascism’.

Facts were neglected as fake news and criticism was berated as anti-nationalism. The far-right movement left no stone unturned to demonize minorities, migrants - both legal and illegal, leftist/socialist parties and liberals, and scaremongering the death of traditional values and national pride by the hands of those sections of the society.

Leaders like Viktor Orban in Hungary, Matteo Salvini in Italy, Jair Bolsanaro in Brazil and the most famous - Donald Trump in the United States are some of the neo-fascist leaders who successfully campaigned their way to the top post of power in their countries. Others in the list include Recep Tayyip Erdogan in Turkey, Rodrigo Duterte in the Philippines and Narendra Modi in India, though their fundamentals of populism is different than their Western peers. Erdogan, Duterte and Modi represent the form of heavy handed, muscular, majoritarian nationalism which have comparable neo-fascist tendencies, but not racially driven.

All these leaders publicly detest liberalism and promote protectionist socio-economic policies. They present themselves to be ‘the Knight in Shining Armour’, who came to save the nation from eminent disaster. While some have managed to bend the media in their country to kiss their toes, other ferociously detest any form of free press as biased and prejudiced. “A conspiracy of Deep State” is a usual excuse given to get away from being held accountable and legitimate criticism.

History is a witness of how Mussolini exploited the precarious political situation in Italy after First World War to assume power. The Great Depression of 1929 and subsequent economic hardships waived the public faith from democracy in countries like Germany. Hitler evoked racial pride and national resurgence as a way to cope up with those problems and demonized Jews and non-Aryans as the sole instigator of Germany’s failure. The on-ground fundamentals then and now seems somewhat parallel.

Public dissatisfaction is rife and exploiters are plenty. Can this mean a revival of nuance form of Fascism with 21st Century characteristics? Indications in elections and public mood suggests so, but it may have peaked and show signs of receding in coming years. After all, a better educated and technologically connected world is better equipped to deal with Fascist induced ignorance.

Tuesday, 19 February 2019

Furor over faith

Image credit: Hindustan Times
On the day of Valentine’s, when couples express their love and affection for each other, a horrifying event unfolded in Kashmir. The terror attack on a CRPF convoy claimed 40 lives in Pulwama in late afternoon, one that was described as a deafening explosion by witnesses on the scene. Over the last 4 days, you have come across the saddening reports of the ghastly attack in news media sprinkled with a dose of rage and retribution. We all noticed the live coverage and prime time segments on news channel over the incident for 3 consecutive days. And there then, it started, a campaign for chest-thumping hyper nationalism with overdose of patriotic hashtags on social media.

The outrage over the dastardly attack carried by a terrorist was driven by emotional sentiments which was justified to the extent where we felt as One Country, One People united at a time of grief and mourning for our martyrs. Indians, rich and poor, kids and adults, men and women, all came under one banner to condemn the atrocity, and console the families of those fallen heroes. Candle light marches and vigils in the name of those martyrs flooded the streets along with a string of international solidarity behind our back. The narrative turned upside down when some “over sentimentalists” mistaken public outrage as calls for public action.

Image credit: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis
Image credit: REUTERS/Mukesh Gupta
We all ran across the visuals of rail roko in Mumbai suburban railways to car torching in Delhi to outright destruction of public property in Jammu. The chaos and havoc invoked due to the overdose of sentiments and miscreant behaviour of some clearly disrupted the day for thousands of others. Targeting Kashmiri students and tenants in cities like Dehradun was another sickening episode in the saga of wilderness staged by the fanatic few. The fuel for that fire was overtly dispensed by the fundamentalists on TV news panels and far-right preachers of blind patriotism. What should have been peaceful foot marches with the Tricolor became violent rowdiness on triple seated bikes fluttering Saffron flags. The underlying idea and intent behind such display was undimmed with the hands and face of the puppeteers luminously visible.

The fact that the person who carried out the attack was a ‘Kashmiri’ youth, not ‘Indian’, resonates a well orchestrated campaign in the media to distinguish Kashmiris with the rest of India. A native to the state of Jammu and Kashmir, an integral part of India, Adil Ahmad Dar, 22, was a local of the place where he carried out his attack. Influenced and radicalized by Jaish-e-Mohammad and alienated by the activities of the state, he resorted to the gravest of grave act for a cause he believed was driven by religious appropriation and freedom struggle. The question, the people in power and media but also the common man, failed to ask is why this happened in the first place? Why that feeling of alienation budded inside his heart? Why that promising young mind diverted attention from intellectual development to extremist propaganda? Why JeM found a diehard recruit across the border on Indian soil? Why he enjoyed sympathies in the hearts of those few in our side of the border? These are some straight solid questions that we failed to get answers from our establishment. Will you agree if I say that we all are partly responsible for the mess festering in that region for decades? Isn’t there a need for introspection among the establishment, the media and the people to get answers? We hail ourselves as the largest democracy in the world while constantly overlooking the rampant tossing of civil and electoral liberties of people whom we still hesitate to call “Indian”. And mind when I say, its not just about Kashmir but also the states at the Eastern edge of the Himalayas.

Then comes to the question of retaliation and retribution. While I prefer not to comment on the heavy words used by our political leadership and the actual weight it carries, I notice that the chest thumping, saffron clad patriots on the streets and on T.V. are distantly floating aboard a dicey boat with perilous ideas. With arguments ranging from nuclear annihilation of Pakistan to indiscriminate shootings of Pakistanis currently in India to launching airstrikes over Karachi, I am sure you too are baffled by the very words of it. Such war-mongering attitudes erupt every time there are cross border militant activities with high casualties, both civilian and military. Remember the tough talks of 2001-02 after the Parliament attack, 2006 bombings of Mumbai suburban trains and the gruesome massacre of men, women and children during the three day siege of 26/11, all brought the mass opinion in favour of such actions. What saved us then and what will save us now is we detest ourselves from such desolate thoughts that are championed by ill-advised and naive minds.

The much lauded and politicized Surgical Strikes post-Uri is a lucid example of the magnitude and limits to our tactical and strategic response. The Bollywood blockbuster of last month, Uri, garnered applause for its depiction of the strikes but very few underlined the ripple effect it’ll implode overtime, whose shock waves are already being felt. Uri, with due respect to its heroic storyline, is a catalyst that’s invoking a new brand of “blockbuster machismo” that feeds to the commoner’s imagination that military action is the answer for all problems and a nationalist political leadership can green light that effort. However the argument slip to gauge the merits of its accomplishments and more so, the collateral damage accompanied. There is a reason that such classified activities in Western countries are concealed from the public for a period of time and only years later can a filmmaker gain access to the story for adaptation. In the temptation to gain political mileage and storm the box office, politicians and filmmakers alike have started capitalizing on sensitive military accomplishments for votes and notes. Audience too are getting carried away in this ride not recognizing the genuine narrative independence and autonomy that the armed forces require.
 
 Image credit: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis
As to the response you think India should give, will be best to keep under the realm of the military and the top political leadership. They are far more tuned and well versed with the economics of retaliation. If we wish to make a change and obscurely punish the perpetrators, let’s start with the small things we can do to harm them. It is a well known fact that our giant neighbor China has repeatedly blocked India’s attempt to designate JeM chief Masood Azhar as a global terrorist in the UN and its subordinate agencies. Worse so, the Chinese response to the Pulwama attacks, both through its foreign office and state media, has been tepid and seen to bend heavily in Pakistan’s favour. Their all-weather alliance banked on Chinese debt-funded Pakistani hopes to keep afloat its ailing economy and strategic access to Arabian Sea in return is a tight knot of dependence. By this, we can understand why its critical for the Chinese to prop up its increasingly isolated ally. To inflict pain on China, we as common citizens can cut purchases of cheap Chinese goods that they have flooded in our market and so help our domestic industry. Dumping the Dragon’s coercive policies can to a mild extent, be a befitting response. Instead of destroying public and private property of fellow Indians, chest-thumpers can boycott cheap Chinese goods, hurting their extravagant trade surplus ($50 billion+) over India, and there they can have a sweet taste of revenge.

At the end, its all a matter of time that we’ll start to see what the establishment does or does not. Having faith in their capacity and trust in their judgement is the best we can do for our martyred heroes. Contributing to charity funds that’ll help their families and praying for their well-being is a service that’s virtuous. So lets heal ourselves of our grief and stay united while keeping away chest-thumping hyper nationalists from setting the stage.