Today, the Narendra Modi led BJP government completes its four years in office. It was on 26th of May, 2014 that he took the oath of office to be the 14th Prime Minister of India. With an energy, slogan and action packed campaign, Modi started his run to victory since the day of his nomination as the PM candidate for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in September 2013. Since then, he won his party the key states of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh before striking a landslide win with absolute majority, first in 30 years, in the general election.
The promise of “Acche Din” and Good Governance resonated the demands of the common masses. A government who will cut red tape for businesses and ease state control over market was something almost every business class individual wanted, and so Mr. Modi promised. A party that’ll move beyond its traditional ideological goals of a Ram Mandir in Ayodhya and Uniform Civil Code, embossed in its old-guard cadre, was a makeover agenda set to bring in voters of the minority communities behind Modi. Employment to the youth, corruption free government, rationalized welfare schemes and assertive foreign policy were the shloks of 2014’s Modi Mantra. On the 4th anniversary, how much of this Mantra proved to be successful.
As each an every Indian reading this now is dissatisfied with the relentless rise in petrol and diesel prices, it is imperative to say that things are not as they expected. Inflation in India is the hottest topic in socio-political discussion, and so if you want to judge this government on the basis of it, there are two facts to consider before an argument.
First is the great dependence of India on imported fuel (almost 70%) to run the engine of the economy. Since 2014, international crude oil prices plummeted to record lows due to a global surplus in stocks. This in turn kept inflation under control as low fuel prices capped transportation costs. Hence in the initial years of the Modi government, inflation remained under 4% of RBI's target. But now, as crude prices rise, we can feel the tight pinch of it on our household budgets as local fuel prices in turn is driving retail inflation up.
Second is the poor infrastructure on the supply side of agricultural goods. India is the second biggest producer of agricultural items but it is because of poor irrigation coverage on the farmlands and poor supply side infrastructure that we are unable to satisfy first our domestic and then global demand. Modi government's push to irrigation and building storage and supply facilities for the farmers after two devastating droughts in 2014 and 2015 haven’t actually materialized the main motto. India still faces chronic wastage of goods after harvest due to lack of proper storage and dwindling water reserves are cramping production. The agrarian distress of rural India has turned into a political hedge game as populist policies like loan waiver has attracted votes for BJP in Maharashtra and U.P. but at same time have drained the states' coffers with little to spend on irrigation and supply side infrastructure development.
Job creation was the single biggest promise on which the BJP engineered the “Modi Wave”. A promise of 2 crore jobs a year and propping up the economy by cutting red tape and taxes is again a hotly debated issue today. Nowhere in the government's own estimates suggest that the former promise has been met. India doesn’t have a reliable national jobs data, though the government is trying to develop one, and so we depend upon various numbers provided by the Labour ministry and private surveys to paint a picture of the job market. As India has a large informal sector which employs the bulk of the working population, the government has tried to migrate these workers in the formal economy through bold reforms like demonetization and Good and Services Tax (GST). While these two clamped down on the informal, untaxed sectors and pushed many to bring their businesses in the formal economy, initiatives like Make In India, Mudra Yojana and Start Up India encouraged local manufacturing, cheap loans to new MSMEs and entrepreneurship respectively. However the actual impacts of such big bang initiatives can only be felt, for now, by those who profited from it, like new entrepreneurs and their new employees.
The single most important reform under the government, GST, was envisioned to be revolutionary, but a hasty intent to roll it out and subsequent faulty implementation actually harmed the economy than helping it, in initial months. The economic horrors of the two policy injections actually made thousands jobless. Though medium and long term impacts of the dua are expected to be favourable.
Foreign policy is by far the least attended issue by the common electorate. Majority of the population may see it as an extension of a Union government's duties. However, we forget that even domestic issues are influenced by foreign policy. One area that the Modi administration can claim near success is foreign policy. Modi has given a personal touch on the foreign policy of India, which for decades were handled just by External Affairs minister and it’s troupe in the South Block of Delhi. From building strong, overtly cosy relationship with Israel, even visiting Jerusalem as the first Indian PM to do so, to having a surprise landing at Lahore to personally greet former Pakistani PM Nawaz Sharif on his birthday and unofficial visits to Chinese and Russian Presidents within one month, Modi has drawn a new picture of how India deliberates on it’s foreign policy. He has embraced the U.S., looking to seek investments and high end technology and also to gain a shoulder support to enter multinational nuclear forums like the NSG and arms control regimes like MTCR. India has comfortably neutralized it’s position on the unending rivalry in the Middle East between Saudi Arabia and Iran and has kept both of them under a friendly sphere of influence. Delicate issues like the 2017 Doklam standoff with China and near daily ceasefire violations and terrorist infiltration attempts along the border with Pakistan have also been dealt with strong arm diplomacy. However, with ever increasing Chinese strategic designs bearing fruit in South Asia and Indian Ocean Region, India has by far remained ineffective to counter immediate challenges to its influence and is slowly catching up. The shunning of Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) by India did send a strong message to China that it will not compromise it’s sovereignty over J&K for rosy economic deals, which have proved to be debt traps in countries like Sri Lanka and Pakistan. Modi’s personal appeal and popularity among the Indian diaspora across the globe has skyrocketed and thus has gained attention by international media, who previously had a conservative, third world country like attitude towards India.
Coming back to India's domestic political domain, the Modi government has maintained a clean, scam free image, thereby cheering his slogan of Good Governance.
The demonetization of November 2016, with an aim to curb Black money and parallel economy, has yielded mixed results. It would be right to criticize the introduction of 2000 rupee bills which will actually aid the creation of black money over time; also to the fact that people managed to convert their illicit income into so called “white money” as data from the RBI shows nearly 98% of all demonetized currency in circulation came back. Yet, another side of the story is that this shock noteban actually brought new taxpayers in the tax net by adding nearly 1.8 million of them in just one year ending in November 2017. This has substantially raised the revenue dividend of the Union government. Crackdown on illicit money stashed both in India and abroad have become daily newspaper articles. Even a tight scrutiny of FDIs from Mauritius and Singapore, which are the most favoured Asian destination for tax evading Indians, had resulted in renegotiated taxation agreements with them. Then again, cases like Nirav Modi and Vijay Mallya makes the common man wonder, is the government really serious about catching economic offenders? Whether the government is able to bring them back to India to face justice is something that everyone will look out for.
Socially, the BJP government is responsible for mild reactions and sometimes even turning a blind eye to rising atrocities against Dalits and religious minorities. The gruesome lynching of Muslims and Dalits “accused” of killing cows and consuming or selling beef has grabbed national headlines. Rising cow vigilantism, forced conversions and violent reprisals to a more liberal and westernised youth by far-right fringe groups like the Bajrang Dal has been overlooked and sometimes even denied by local ruling party figures. Such right wing Hindu groups have ideological affinity with BJP parent, RSS, and looks at the Modi government as an umbrella to protect them from scrutiny and law enforcement, thereby making them more hawkish.
At the end, there’s more than just these couple of paragraphs that talks about the 4 years of the Modi government. The BJP has managed to increase its influence in other parts of the country, most notably the North East, post 2014. From ruling just 7 states before 2014 general elections, it now rules 21 of India’s 29 states along with it’s allies. Most of them have a full majority BJP government. The few remaining areas yet to penetrate are West Bengal, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Odisha and Telangana, where the party is gaining considerable influence quickly.
![]() |
| image credit; mapsofindia.com |
The prime opposition Congress Party under Rahul Gandhi has struggled to hold its political influence and is seen by analysts as slowly being overshadowed by more powerful regional parties. The talk of a united opposition is gaining steam but internal factionalism and overtly ambitious aims of regional party leaders is casting a doubt of whether such an alliance be formed, and even if it does, can it give a tough fight to Modi and the BJP, which as a strong cadre base and a PM who still holds unchallenged popularity and charisma among the masses. The BJP under Modi-Shah is hailed as a formidable political force with traits of military precision and corporate efficiency.
What the race in 2019 will look like is becoming unpredictable by the day. With a flurry of rhetoric, accusations and socially divisive agendas on social and news media gaining steam, it is surely going to be a battle of popularity, strength and personal conviction between Modi and his supposed opponent, with many suggesting it to be Rahul Gandhi.




No comments:
Post a Comment